I don’t have to point out that today’s teachers are frustrated – that they’re too often forced to teach content, and in ways, that’s not at all helpful to kids and their future. As they prep students to meet standards and pass an endless number of tests, teachers frequently lament the fact that there’s no time to get the “good stuff” into the curriculum.
Well, teacher Justin Minkel asserts that it’s not an either/or scenario between passing on the basic skills meant to be tested and the important things – like higher-order thinking, creativity, design skills, and inquiry. The latter, he says, don’t have to be an “extracurricular bonus.”
To explore this further, I invited Justin, along with educator Jason Flom, who told me he loves this topic, to join me for an episode of Studentcentricity.
During our discussion Justin talked about some of the projects that allow him to weave basic skills and the important stuff together. But he added that projects aren’t always the vehicle. Afterward, he sent me the following:
Teaching "the good stuff" doesn't always have to involve a long project with lots of moving parts. Take reading: most of the reading instruction in my class involves kids actually reading real books--like Pam Munoz Ryan's historical novel "Riding Freedom," Mo Willems' hilarious "Piggie and Elephant" series, and anything by Kate di Camillo. Sub-skills from the Standards like summaries, compare/contrast, or using strategies for unknown words are always taught through those great books, not through worksheets.
I think sometimes we break complex abilities down into their separate parts but fail to give kids enough opportunities to put those pieces back together again. Reading is often broken into 20-minute periods of the day when students highlight phonics worksheets, drill sight words, or practice comprehension skills in isolation. All of that is fine, but they need the opportunity to put everything together into the complicated, satisfying act of actually reading a book.
Justin also spends a great deal of time examining how students spend their time in his classroom. (You can read his article, “Hard Truths: Examining How Students Spend Their Time in Our Classrooms,” here.) Below are his thoughts, encapsulated:
Movies like Freedom Writers and Dangerous Minds have prepared us to think that good teaching is all about what the teacher does and says--her or his eloquence, passion, and inspiring story. But we learn over time that good teaching is actually all about what the students say, do, and think--their eloquence, their passion, and their stories. I try to think through each lesson, day, and week from the point of view of a child in my class. How much do the students get to talk, as opposed to listening to me talk? How much do they get to move around? How many choices do they make, and how many opportunities do they have to build things, write stories, read great books, and solve complicated problems? Above all else, what is happening in their minds throughout a day in my class?
You can hear my conversation with Justin and Jason by clicking here.