• Home
    Home This is where you can find all the blog posts throughout the site.
  • Categories
    Categories Displays a list of categories from this blog.
  • Tags
    Tags Displays a list of tags that have been used in the blog.
  • Bloggers
    Bloggers Search for your favorite blogger from this site.
  • Archives
    Archives Contains a list of blog posts that were created previously.
  • Login
    Login Login form

Open-ended Activities: One Right Definition?

Posted by on in Early Childhood
  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Hits: 4970

I have been teaching Art, Music and Movement to college students for a while. There are certain concepts we try to get across to practitioners that are important to ECE professionals, and encouraged by our professional organization, NAEYC. One of those concepts is the idea of open-ended activities.

What are open-ended activities?  Do you put out a mass of materials and say, “Go get ‘em”, like one workshop participant opined? If you change materials, are you being too “teacher-ish”?

Well, yes and no…

Because many tend to think, in this post-social media age, that each question has a right and a wrong; that the right is might, and the wrong is way too strong, we have trouble seeing the grey areas. Perhaps I’d rather say the value areas. In art, adding white or black to a color changes its value. When we consider concepts, our values may change a tiny bit or a lot, depending on what is added or subtracted. So, as Diane Kashin has written, there is a continuum between a concept such as “open-ended” and its opposite. Open-ended might mean throw the lot of your materials on a table and see what they do, and closed might mean giving children directions and materials, saying what they must do with them (generally not recommended!). But in between, ah, there is a rainbow of values!

This week we have been studying bones at my center. The topic of bones was child-generated. Some of the children’s questions were, “What holds the head bone up?”, and “what is inside the spine?” We took out body books from the library. I bought a cool magnetic puzzle with bones on one side, and the under-the-bones view on the opposite side for the children to assemble on the fridge. My teaching partner brought out our collection of deer bones and skulls (courtesy of a former parent who was a hunter). One child brought in a raccoon skull that he and his family found outdoors.

These materials were for inquiry, manipulation, comparison, and questioning. Children touched, sketched, and discussed.

Meanwhile, coming into the building one day, we stopped to admire the two year olds’ silhouettes that were hung all along the hallway. An idea came up.

The next day we traced our children’s bodies, and then asked them to draw, on their silhouettes, what they had learned about the body, specifically bones. What they did was open-ended in that they made choices. Should I draw a skull or a face? Should I draw veins and arteries or bones? Do I include joints? They drew what most impressed them so that each was different, and an individual expression of their learning in the moment. 

This project (which continues—there is some discussion of dinosaurs bones!) demonstrates that activities can be both teacher and child directed, (another concept to examine as a continuum, as Ms. Kashin suggests), and can be open, but guided.

Did we measure up to the standards of the open-ended advocates? Perhaps not. But we were somewhere in the rainbow of values. And the children were satisfied.

Last modified on
Rate this blog entry:

Gail teaches Early Childhood Education as an Adjunct Associate Professor for Northern Virginia Community College, one of the largest community college systems in the country. She is a popular trainer in the DC area, leading workshops on such topics as Engaging, Arts-Based and Outdoor Learning, and Guiding Behavior. She is a member of the Virginia Community College Peer Group which collaborates with the Virginia Department of Social Services to train and license childcare professionals throughout the state. Her blog on BAM's EdWords is referenced in several arts websites, and is used in Early Childhood courses throughout Virginia. She is also a member of NAREA, the North American Reggio Emilia Alliance. You can contact her for more information about Professional Development opportunities. 

Gail lives and works in Northern Virginia. Her special interests include arts-integration, play, Reggio Emilia, music and yoga. 

  • No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment

Leave your comment

Guest Saturday, 23 February 2019